Shame on Business Insider, Gizmodo, et al. for quoting anonymous Quora answer as fact for pageviews!

July 8, 2011 § 19 Comments

By: Michael Sinanian

This blog has discussed Quora’s transformative effect on journalism before, bringing to light its disruptive potential on content commoditization and branding.

But over the fourth of July, a lot of this “news innovation” was effectively tossed out the window. The transgression? Prominent tech blog Silicon Alley Insider ran a story that was entirely derived from an anonymous Quora answer with no attribution what so ever.

Addressing a question about potential uses for Apple’s astronomically large cash hoard, the user wrote a lengthy answer that received over 570 up-votes and a long stream of congratulatory comments. [1]

Without reliable attribution, this answer should not be up-voted so enthusiastically and it certainly shouldn’t be repackaged and resold by the blogosphere as “news analysis.” This should be a lesson for both journalists and Quora users alike: well-worded answers that tell us what we want to hear aren’t necessarily good answers.

Other “respectable” sites also ran this story, including Forbes, Fortune, and Gizmodo, which went as far as to title their story “Is Apple So Far Ahead Because They Use Tech From the Future?”

Such titles are worthy of the term “link-bait” for their pure intention of securing re-tweets and re-posts to drive up page views, regardless of editorial value.

Although a win for Quora, whose content is now apparently so valuable as to be quoted without a shred of doubt by major tech news outlets, this is a sore disappointment for Journalism 2.0.

Silicon Alley Insider and all the other blogs that followed suit in reposting this should be ashamed of themselves. It’s stunts like these that make “blogging” a derogatory term in the face of “real” journalism.

Furthermore, as proud members of the Quora community, we must ask ourselves what’s permissible to up-vote. Sourceless answers like the one discussed may still be correct despite a lack of attribution, but that should be taken into consideration when deciding how to vote or sourcing it for a story.

This approval dilemma has arisen in other ways, too. We’ve all witnessed a highly up-voted answer simply because the content is well-worded or emotionally engaging, despite questionable correctness.

Unfortunately, Quora’s current approval mechanisms don’t have much granularity. We are only provided the blunt instruments of an up-vote, a down-vote, or a meaningless “thank you” note. It’s not possible to simultaneously up-vote for writing style but down-vote for attribution.

Despite such shortcomings, Quora does have a system in place that allows reviewers to specify why egregious answers need improvement in certain areas. Without opening this up to most of the user-base, however, content is still liable to be improperly credited on a wide scale.

For those of us who are enthusiastic users or people who use Quora for journalism, we must be careful. Our actions are these missing granular controls, and we must be cautious in their use.

[1] – The only attribution comes in the form of a few commenters who link to articles from earlier in the year that vaguely go over what the answerer talks about. This does provide some credence to the matter, but not enough for wholesale replication by other news outlets.

[2] – This is cross-posted from a personal Quora post which can be found here: http://www.quora.com/Michael-Sinanian/Shame-on-the-Blogosphere-and-Quora-Users

Tagged: , , , , , , , , ,

§ 19 Responses to Shame on Business Insider, Gizmodo, et al. for quoting anonymous Quora answer as fact for pageviews!

  • […] my guest piece today in The Quora Review: This blog has discussed Quora’s transformative effect on journalism before, bringing to light […]

  • Tony Schpierer says:

    Quora’s policy on requiring one’s real name is both an invasion of privacy and a deterrent to those who would like to contribute useful information ( with appropriate references) but need to protect their privacy for priofessinal and personal safety reasons. Because of that I must unequivocally discourage any participation in this “predatorial” organization – whose value ( as with ALL other Internet information sources ) should be regarded as primarily entertainment… Shame on you Quora!

  • But since the best way to locate lasting self-actualization is to perform so
    legitimately, the consumer is locked inside a
    repetitive cycle of according to another method that’s both fleeting
    and preventative to actual self-actualization. They
    will quickly miss you and will want to spend more hours together with you.

    This degree also prepares students to pursue seminary or graduate degrees, including Maranatha’s Master of Divinity or Master of Arts in Biblical Counseling.

    Part with the salary a person can earn is determined by where they
    work.

  • It started with i – Phone and possesses now moved to
    i – Pad 2; the reason- lack of availability.
    Just just because a link is on Piratebay does
    not necessarily mean that the users are installing,
    so because of this, the flawed data. There are a handful of
    significant improvements made over Vista, but for the most part, it’s just a version of Vista that is certainly both stable
    and more user-friendly.

  • As people open the files beyond there torrent directory
    the seeds dry and the. When you will be making a juice from dark,
    leafy greens, try adding a little cucumber.
    When you have a file you wish to share, you can upload it to your
    storage account.

  • Bradly says:

    It’s hard to find your posts in google. I found it on 19 spot, you should build quality backlinks
    , it will help you to increase traffic. I know how to help you, just search in google – k2 seo tips and tricks

  • Justina says:

    I read a lot of interesting content here. Probably you spend a lot of time writing, i
    know how to save you a lot of work, there is an online tool that creates high
    quality, google friendly posts in seconds, just type in google – k2seotips unlimited content

  • Joint pain foods – fruits, as they provide strength and grease
    joints to the joints between the bananas is considered to be the best.
    Corticosteroids are helpful especially when you have cancer that has spread to
    the brain, spine, and the bone. 3) Hot steaming and massage with
    essential oils also acts as a great remedy for arthritis.

  • When he stops falling he will start to laugh because its fun.
    Takes a bit of believing, doesn’t it, but I’ve read that great
    sportsmen and women, and people who’ve suffered through terrible catastrophes, all have had the ability of gaining mastery over their
    physical states through their mental strength.
    Children shouldn’t spend the majority of their childhood on drugs to calm them
    down if there is an alternative.

  • Flirting Tip Number 1 – Establishing a Physical Connection. I also had a past-life reading that, although, not as in-depth as a regression, was fascinating and extremely helpful to
    me in this life all the same. The reason why you should receive a free psychic reading if you are looking into numerology
    is because many psychics have different interpretations and meanings for all of the numbers.

  • Ltd also has its agents for retail sale and export. The app does excel in what it promises to do and a frequent wine drinker and
    tracker will be able to really make use of it. I just program the Favorites Cycle, in your microwave.

  • Nummunal Eczema may also be due to other causes such
    as: an allergic reaction to the excrement from house dust mites, allergy to
    foodstuffs including :. Thereby the itching and scratching get prevented, and possibly
    you can come out from this vicious cycle. Of course, not all types of food trigger eczema on face.

  • Dietary fat has long been blamed for causing obesity, but experts now say high-fat, low
    carb diets such as the Paleo, Atkins and ketogenic plans
    beat low-fat diets for weight loss because eating fat can make you skinny.
    If only they knew that an uncomplicated recipe book like the Paleo Cookbook is good enough to do wonders for them,
    some might have used up their means on some other things instead.
    Wash hands thoroughly after handling raw chicken before
    handling other foods and objects.

  • Katherine says:

    The unit could be capped with a visit to the art museum. It’s
    not as simple as some individuals make it sound. Nonetheless, homeschooling
    a special needs child is guaranteed by the United States Constitution.

  • Unaware their conversations were being recorded, Thompson said
    he had numerous discussions over the past 10 months with Dr.
    Exercise regularly, obtain adequate sleep and drink plenty of purified water.
    If you have trouble finding a dentist with such experience, your best option is to choose
    one who has compassion and a willingness to learn.

  • The best way to do that is to compare all of the bartending schools in your area.
    This also reveals often the bartender within teaching purchasing these
    kinds of tense circumstances in a very stress-free and as well ,.
    By practicing this skill having a bartender which you trust, begin.

  • What have you learned from your spiritual guide for
    meditation and numerous books on spirituality, yoga and meditation, practice regularly and repeatedly until it becomes a
    habit. Spiritual Enlightenment is impulsive when extends beyond the limits of your
    spiritual life and spiritual meditation. No wonder schools like Shri
    Aurobindo School and Dayanand Public school
    came up.

  • Patrick’s day is an marvelous way to say happy holidays.
    However, you may decide to just draw a simple flower on your cake.
    With the use of this tool, putting your choice of frosting on the cake can be smooth and easy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading Shame on Business Insider, Gizmodo, et al. for quoting anonymous Quora answer as fact for pageviews! at The Quora Review.

meta

%d bloggers like this: